Punitive Damages against Trustee

Surcharge imposed against trustee for more than $600,000 for “reimbursements” to herself, but surcharge for failure to properly invest funds denied because the testimony of the expert witness was speculative and simplistic and lacked a solid foundation.  In addition, punitive damages of more than $300,000 imposed for conduct the court found to be intentional and reckless.  Simple interest imposed at the legal rate of 6% from the date of each “distribution” the trustee made to herself.  Gansky Trust, 4 Fid.Rep.3d 330 (O.C. Montg. 2015) (opinion by Ott, J.)

On exceptions, the surcharge was recalculated, simple interest at 6% was affirmed, punitive damages were denied, and attorney fees for the objectants were denied.  Gansky Trust, 6 Fid.Rep.3d 27 (O.C. Montg. 2015) (opinion by Murphy and Ott, JJ.).

Claims Allowed for Expenses Paid by Friends of Decedent

Claims allowed for expenses paid by friends of the decedent (one of whom was a cousin of the decedent) for taxes on property of the decedent, as well as insurance and utilities, for hospice care for the decedent before death, and for the funerals and burials of both the decedent and her husband, who had died a few months before, and whose burial was therefore an obligation of the decedent.  Miller Estate, 6 Fid.Rep.3d 23 (O.C. Allegh. 2015).

Executors Surcharged for Self-Dealing and Mismanagement

Executors surcharged for sale of estate property to a son of one executor, for expenses paid to the purchaser of the property for “cleanup” of the property 20 days before the sale, for distributions of automobiles contrary to the provisions of the will, for the value of assets shown on the inheritance tax return but not the account, for a discrepancy between the difference between the amounts shown as receipts and disbursements in the account and the amounts actually distributed, and for executor commissions paid in the face of acts of self-dealing, but surcharges denied for payments for utilities after decedent’s death, for a partial payment on a debt for which the decedent co-signed, and for distributions of personal property in the absence of evidence as to the nature and value of the property distributed.  Attorney fees for the objectant were not awarded, and removal of executors was denied.  Rehrig Estate, 6 Fid.Rep.3d 13 (O.C. Northampt. 2015).

Federal Estate and Gift Tax Rates and Exclusions

The following is a chart of the federal estate tax exclusions. the bottom and top tax rates that have been in effect since 1977 (assuming no taxable gifts before 1977), and the federal gift tax annual exclusions.  The federal gift tax lifetime exclusion amounts were the same as the estate tax exclusions, except for the years 2004 through 2010, when the federal gift tax exclusion amount was limited to $1,000,000.

Year


Estate Tax Exclusion

Estate Tax Initial Rate (Above Exclusion)

Estate Tax Maximum Rate

Gift Tax Annual Exclusion

1977

$120,667

30%

70%

$3,000

1978

$134,000

30%

70%

$3,000

1979

$147,333

30%

70%

$3,000

1980

$161,563

32%

70%

$3,000

1981

$175,625

32%

70%

$3,000

1982

$225,000

32%

65%

$10,000

1983

$275,000

34%

60%

$10,000

1984

$325,000

34%

55%

$10,000

1985

$400,000

34%

55%

$10,000

1986

$500,000

37%

55%

$10,000

1987-1996

$600,000

37%

55%

$10,000

1997

$600,000

37%

60%[1]

$10,000

1998

$625,000

37%

60%[1]

$10,000

1999

$650,000

37%

60%[1]

$10,000

2000-2001

$675,000

37%

60%[1]

$10,000

2002

$1,000,000

41%

50%

$11,000

2003

$1,000,000

41%

49%

$11,000

2004

$1,500,000

45%

48%

$11,000

2005

$1,500,000

45%

47%

$11,000

2006

$2,000,000

46%

46%

$12,000

2007-2008

$2,000,000

45%

45%

$12,000

2009

$3,500,000

45%

45%

$13,000

2010[2]-2011

$5,000,000

35%

35%

$13,000

2012

$5,120,000

35%

35%

$13,000

2013

$5,250,000

40%

40%

$14,000

2014

$5,340,000

40%

40%

$14,000

2015

$5,430,000

40%

40%

$14,000

2016

$5,450,000

40%

40%

$14,000

2017

$5,490,000

40%

40%

$14,000

2018

$11,180,000 [3]

40%

40%

$15,000

2019

$11,400,000

40%

40%

$15,000

2020

$11,580,000

40%

40%

$15,000

2021

$11,700,000

40%

40%

$15,000

2022

$12,060,000

40%

40%

$16,000

2023

$12,920,000 [4]

40%

40%

$17,000 [4]

2024

$13,610,000

40%

40%

$18,000

Notes to table:

[1]  The 60% maximum tax rate actually represents an additional 5% that was added to estates of more than $10,000,000 from the years 1997 to 2001 in order to eliminate the benefit of the progressive tax table.  The additional 5% ended at a taxable estate of $17,184,000, which is when the average tax rate reached 55%.  So the top marginal tax rate during those years was 60%, but the top average tax rate was 55%.

[2]  The federal estate tax in 2010 was actually optional, and estates could elect to pay no estate tax and instead accept a limit on the increase in the income tax basis on assets included in the estate.

[3]  The basic exclusion amount was doubled in 2018, but that doubling ends after 2025.

[4]  Official figure published in Rev. Proc.  Rev. Proc. 2022-38.

Vacating Local Orphans’ Court Rules

After entering an order adopting new Orphans’ Court rules, generally effective September 1, 2016 (see In re: Order Rescinding and Replacing Rules 1.1 through 13.3 and Rule 17, and Amendment Rules 14.1 through 16.12 of the Pennsylvania Orphans Court Rules, No. 682 Supreme Court Rules Docket (12/1/2015), 45 Pa.B. 7098 (12/19/2015)), the Supreme Court entered an order directing that local rules for which there is a “continued necessity” should be submitted to the Orphans’ Court Procedural Rules Committee for review no later than June 1, 2016.

Local rules that are not reviewed and adopted under new Pa.O.C. Rule 1.5 shall be vacated effective September 1, 2016.

Review and Vacatur of Local Orphans’ Court Rules, No. 683 Supreme Court Rules Docket (12/1/2015), 45 Pa.B. 7126 (12/19/2015).

New Basis Reporting Form

The Internal Revenue Service has released a 12/18/2015 draft of a new Form 8971 for reporting basis information in accordance with new IRC section 6035 for assets held by a decedent and reported on a federal estate tax return (Form 706) filed on or after August 1, 2015.

As previously reported, the IRS has delayed the due date for the new reporting requirements until February 29, 2016.  See Notice 2015-57.

Applicable Federal Rates for 2015

HTML Version Copyright 2015-2024 Daniel B. Evans. All rights reserved.


— Short Term Rates for 2015 —

MonthAnnualSemiann.QuarterlyMonthly
Jan.0.41%0.41%0.41%0.41%
Feb.0.48%0.48%0.48%0.48%
March0.40%0.40%0.40%0.40%
April0.48%0.48%0.48%0.48%
May0.43%0.43%0.43%0.43%
June0.43%0.43%0.43%0.43%
July0.48%0.48%0.48%0.48%
Aug.0.48%0.48%0.48%0.48%
Sept.0.54%0.54%0.54%0.54%
Oct.0.55%0.55%0.55%0.55%
Nov.0.49%0.49%0.49%0.49%
Dec.0.56%0.56%0.56%0.56%

— Mid Term Rates for 2015 —

MonthAnnualSemiann.QuarterlyMonthly
Jan.1.75%1.74%1.74%1.73%
Feb.1.70%1.69%1.69%1.68%
March1.47%1.46%1.46%1.46%
April1.70%1.69%1.69%1.68%
May1.53%1.52%1.52%1.52%
June1.60%1.59%1.59%1.58%
July1.77%1.76%1.76%1.75%
Aug.1.82%1.81%1.81%1.80%
Sept.1.77%1.76%1.76%1.75%
Oct.1.67%1.66%1.66%1.65%
Nov.1.59%1.58%1.58%1.57%
Dec.1.68%1.67%1.67%1.66%

 — Long Term Rates for 2015 —

MonthAnnualSemiann.QuarterlyMonthly
Jan.2.67%2.65%2.64%2.64%
Feb.2.41%2.40%2.39%2.39%
March2.19%2.18%2.17%2.17%
April2.47%2.45%2.44%2.44%
May2.30%2.29%2.28%2.28%
June2.50%2.48%2.47%2.47%
July2.74%2.72%2.71%2.70%
Aug.2.82%2.80%2.79%2.78%
Sept.2.64%2.62%2.61%2.61%
Oct.2.58%2.56%2.55%2.55%
Nov.2.57%2.55%2.54%2.54%
Dec.2.61%2.59%2.58%2.58%